New users to CPDL and the wiki sometimes get confused where to address any queries they may have. They may write a message on their talk page assuming that this will be read by someone. Would it be possible for there to be some standard text appear when one views one's own talk page? A simple line would avoid such a problem. It could read:
"If you want to ask a question, please don't post it here - it is likely that no-one will see it. Instead, sign up on the forums [link] and post your query there or ask an administrator [link]."
Message for users when editing their own talk page
Message for users when editing their own talk page
Rob Nottingham
CPDL Administrator
CPDL Administrator
Re: Message for users when editing their own talk page
Great idea! I've seen reasonably technical users also get confused about this aspect.
Re: Message for users when editing their own talk page
Rob, as far as I'm concerned there is only a general message (MediaWiki:Talkpagetext) that can be added for all talk pages, not just one's own.
If we decide to change this message, I'm not sure if we should direct people straight to the forums. Some people may not be willing to create two accounts and would feel more comfortable staying in the wiki environment, so I'd suggest directing them to the admins' page for contacts first, informing the forum as a second alternative.
Addendum: If I'm not mistaken, I remember having seen Wikipedia display different Talkpagetext's according to context, but I don't know how they do it. Perhaps by using javascript. We could check their code later.
If we decide to change this message, I'm not sure if we should direct people straight to the forums. Some people may not be willing to create two accounts and would feel more comfortable staying in the wiki environment, so I'd suggest directing them to the admins' page for contacts first, informing the forum as a second alternative.
Addendum: If I'm not mistaken, I remember having seen Wikipedia display different Talkpagetext's according to context, but I don't know how they do it. Perhaps by using javascript. We could check their code later.
Re: Message for users when editing their own talk page
I've added appropriate notes and links to the Mediawiki:Talkpagetext which may help clear things up a bit. This additional note appears when a user opens a talk page for editing (sorry that the wiki encoding doesn't get translated/displayed properly here):
Perhaps I should make the addition conditional on the User talk: namespace, though.
Addendum: I've added code that only displays the additional note on User talk pages, but at present there is no way to make it appear only on a specific user's own talk page.
You can see the effect by opening your own talk page for edit.'''Please note:''' If this is your discussion ("talk") page and you wish to '''''initiate a disucssion''''' with or '''''ask a question''''' of a {{CW}} administrator, please use that administrator's talk page. Do not simply leave a message here on your talk page with the expectation that an administrator will see it. A list of administrators with links to their talk pages is available at [[ChoralWiki:Administrators]]. Alternatively, you may '''login''' at the [index.php '''CPDL Forums'''] (note that separate registration is required) and post a message there in the '''CPDL Discussions''' section which will be read by everyone.
Perhaps I should make the addition conditional on the User talk: namespace, though.
Addendum: I've added code that only displays the additional note on User talk pages, but at present there is no way to make it appear only on a specific user's own talk page.
Charles H. Giffen
CPDL Board of Directors Chair
Admin at & Manager of ChoralWiki
CPDL Board of Directors Chair
Admin at & Manager of ChoralWiki
Re: Message for users when editing their own talk page
I don't see it on my own Talk page, which I'm viewing in logged-in state.
Re: Message for users when editing their own talk page
The message only appears when you Edit a user talk page - and it is an extension of the message that appears when you edit any (nonuser) talk page at ChoralWiki.
Charles H. Giffen
CPDL Board of Directors Chair
Admin at & Manager of ChoralWiki
CPDL Board of Directors Chair
Admin at & Manager of ChoralWiki
Re: Message for users when editing their own talk page
Oops, I see. I think this will be helpful. However, I have a suggestion about what gets bolded.
Right now, "Please note" is the part that's bolded, so the user's eye alights on that and then has to read further into the non-bolded text. I suggest removing the Please note and instead having "If this is your own [adding a word] discussion ("talk") page" be the part that's bolded--that way a person's eye skips to the bold section that allows them to quickly tell if the section following the bolding applies in their situation.
Right now, "Please note" is the part that's bolded, so the user's eye alights on that and then has to read further into the non-bolded text. I suggest removing the Please note and instead having "If this is your own [adding a word] discussion ("talk") page" be the part that's bolded--that way a person's eye skips to the bold section that allows them to quickly tell if the section following the bolding applies in their situation.
Re: Message for users when editing their own talk page
Done! Thanks for the suggestion.vaarky wrote:I suggest removing the Please note and instead having "If this is your own [adding a word] discussion ("talk") page" be the part that's bolded--that way a person's eye skips to the bold section that allows them to quickly tell if the section following the bolding applies in their situation.
Charles H. Giffen
CPDL Board of Directors Chair
Admin at & Manager of ChoralWiki
CPDL Board of Directors Chair
Admin at & Manager of ChoralWiki